Skip to content
Commit 18ecbb47 authored by Mike Isely's avatar Mike Isely Committed by Mauro Carvalho Chehab
Browse files

V4L/DVB (7714): pvrusb2: Fix hang on module removal



The pvrusb2 driver was getting had by this scenario:

1. Task A calls kthread_stop() for task B.
2. Before exiting, then Task B calls kthread_stop() for task C.

The problem is, kthread_stop() wants to allocate an internal resource
to itself (i.e. acquire a lock), which won't be released until
kthread_stop() returns.  But kthread_stop() won't return until task B
is dead.  But task B won't die until it finishes its call to
kthread_stop() for task C, and that will block waiting on the resource
already allocated inside task A.  Deadlock.

With the pvrusb2 driver, task A is the caller to pvr_exit(), task B is
the control thread run inside of pvrusb2-context.c, and task C is any
worker thread run inside of pvrusb2-hdw.c.

This problem got introduced by the previous threading setup change,
which was itself an attempt to fix a module tear-down race (which it
actually did fix).  The lesson here is that a task being waited on as
part of a kthread_stop() simply cannot be allow to also issue a
kthread_stop() - or we make sure not to issue the enclosing
kthread_stop() until we know that the inner kthread_stop() has
completed first.  The solution for the pvrusb2 driver is some hackish
code which changes the main control thread tear down into a two step
process.  This then makes it possible to delay issuing the
kthread_stop() on the control thread until after we know that
everything has been torn down first.  (And yes, we really need that
kthread_stop() because it's the only way to safely guarantee that a
module-referencing kernel thread has safely returned back out of the
module before we finally remove the module.)

Signed-off-by: default avatarMike Isely <isely@pobox.com>
Signed-off-by: default avatarMauro Carvalho Chehab <mchehab@infradead.org>
parent 13e027a8
0% or .
You are about to add 0 people to the discussion. Proceed with caution.
Finish editing this message first!
Please register or to comment